The Rivalry

The Dodgers and Giants took time out of their usual pregame routines tonight to try an diffuse any further violence between LA and SF fans. This unity comes on the heels of the awful attack against Brian Stow in the Dodger Stadium parking lot just after this year’s home opener.

“When the last out is made,” said Giant Jeremy Affeldt, “the rivalry ends on the field.” (For more on the pregame event read the story at

I don’t condone what happened to Brian Stow and I don’t want to make light of it either. But at the same time, I don’t think much is advanced by focusing too much blame on “the rivalry” between these two teams.

As I said on Twitter, I hate the Giants more than just about anybody or anything. And, yet, I have never beaten up one of their fans. This isn’t about the rivalry between our two teams; it’s about a violent attack by two men against one other. Whatever their motivation, their willingness to engage in violence is far more complicated (and more simple) than a rivalry taken to the extreme.

With all due respect to the Dodgers and Giants who spoke before tonight’s game, for me, the rivalry does not end on the field. It is a part of my life, of my love for my team, of my love for the sport. In some small but discernible way, it is part of my identity.

I can understand the need to diffuse the tension of the rivalry at a time like this. For people who carelessly act out of a combination of alcohol, hyper-masculinity, and stupidity, events like tonight might reframe their unquestioned positioning in important (though likely short-lived) ways. But what happened to Brian Stow (much like the thousands of other senseless acts of violence that have befallen people in this state since then) has very little to do with a competitive spirit between “my boys” and “them.”

That said…the Dodgers beat the Giants tonight, 6-1.

3 thoughts on “The Rivalry

  1. Of course the rivalry does not end of the field. That is why it is a rivalry. But general standards of citizenship should not be left at the ticket booth either. Regardless of sports, everyone is human. We can’t lose sight of that. But beyond that, GO DODGERS.

  2. One thing that seems to be missing from the analysis of this whole event … at least I haven’t seen it … is the complicity of the Giants organization in some of the excesses of the past. (Obviously, I can’t speak for the Dodgers … I don’t know how they promote their games.) For a long time now, the Giants have aired special ad campaigns for when the Dodgers come to town. No, the ads don’t say “beat up a Dodger fan.” But they do more than just encourage a friendly rivalry. Having said that, I admit I did not see any such ads this time around.

    Ultimately, alcohol is the prime culprit, far as I can tell. People talk about how the new ballpark’s higher ticket prices bring a better class of fans than used to show up at Candlestick, but that’s nonsense. What has changed is the difficulty in getting drunk.

  3. I feel like that sort of advertising is probably more common in college but it definately does happen universally. I would have to agree that it is the alchohol. The Dodgers organization have talked about reducing beer promotions and such but that fact is alchohol has come to be part of sports. There really is no way around that. The best defense to any of this is probaby just to surround yourself with people you trust, power in numbers right?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s